The players must raise the same-colored flag as the Shy Guy raises. Sometimes, however, the Shy Guy confuses the players with putting up both flags, lowers one, puts down the other, and keeps up the first flag. He will be eliminating the player from the game by cutting the rope holding the barrel the player is in if they raise the wrong flag, is too slow, or does nothing at all. In Mario Party 2, if a player picks the wrong flag or is too slow, the Shy Guy shoots their balloon with an arrow.
- - Raise white flag
- - Raise red flag